Dimensions of Evaluation - (0 = unacceptably flawed, 1 = major and minor flaws limit success,
2 = one major or numerous minor flaws, 3 = perfection spoiled by minor flaws, 4 = superb)
1) Energy and enthusiasm (20%)
2) Clarity (30%)
Presentation (includes titling, cosmetics, and mechanic) (5%)
Sentence and paragraph structure (15%)
Architecture (overall structure) (10%)
3) Insight and analysis (20%)
4) Effectiveness - the extent to which the paper is convincing based on reasoning, and support (20%)
Student:
Paper title or subject:
Dimensions of Evaluation - (0 = unacceptably flawed, 1 = major and minor flaws limit success,
2 = one major or numerous minor flaws, 3 = perfection spoiled by minor flaws, 4 = superb)
1) Energy and enthusiasm (20%)
2) Clarity (30%)
3) Insight and analysis (20%)
4) Effectiveness - the extent to which the paper is convincing based on reasoning, and support (20%)
5) Citation of sources 10%
Overall, in Sum (15 points possible)
Narrative Response: